Circuit Breaker vs Fuse, Which One is Safer and Reliable?
Information Posted in Electronics
Despite of all the advantages circuit breakers have, they still are not capable enough to fully replace the fuses.
To convince you, I am listing a few pros and cons of both of them below which will also help you in making a decision. Time Required to Break the Circuit: A Fuse or a circuit breaker, both have the same purpose which is to break the circuit as quickly as possible to avoid possible burning of equipment and wiring. Circuit breakers are made using mechanical parts which physically move to break the circuit. This movement is usually achieved by using the magnetic field or thermal changes. Fault response time of a circuit breaker is usually more than 10 milliseconds. It is good enough to prevent fires but when it comes to sensitive equipment, this time interval is too long and can easily cause them severe damage.
On the other hand, fuses which we normally use in our houses are built to thermally burn in order to break the circuit. The burning time decreases as the current flow increases which is very beneficial. In case of short circuit where a large flow of current is involved, the fuse will burn far quicker than the tripping ability of a circuit breaker. An average fuse will only take 1 or 2 milliseconds to burn. This gives fuses an edge over circuit breakers. However, fuses do not instantly blow at slight overloads, for example a 15A fuse will not quickly blow at 15.1A or even 16A. On slight overloads it may take several seconds to blow. Usually a non-delaying fuse will need double amps than its rating to blow instantly.
Winner: I think a good fast fuse can easily outperform any circuit breaker so winner of this department is "Fuse" Re-usability: A fuse can only be used once and will need to be replaced after every fault. Circuit breakers can be reset using a button after every overload or short circuit event. It is also much quicker to reset a circuit breaker using a button while it will take a few minutes or more to replace a fuse.
Winner:"Circuit Breaker" wins here.
Cost: Circuit breakers are significantly costlier than fuses. However please keep in mind if you are expecting a lot of overload or short circuit events then the combined cost of fuse replacement can catch up with that of circuit breaker.
Winner:"Fuse" Handing Safety: Fuses are usually placed close to mains therefore changing a fuse is a bit risky task as it involves manual placement of fuse inside fuse box using hands. On the other hand, Circuit breaker can be easily reset using a button which is certainly less risky.
Winner:I think "Circuit Breaker" easily wins. Reliability: Fuses do not have moving parts therefore they do not fail while the most fearsome issue with a circuit breaker is the possibility of failures. Although it is very rare but still sometimes circuit breakers fail to break circuit due to jamming of internal mechanical parts. It can result in burning of entire house or building.
Winner:To me I think the main difference between a circuit breaker and fuse is reliability therefore low chance of failure makes "Fuse" a winner.
Conclusion: After going through all above differences between fuse and circuit breaker, I think it is safer to conclude that fuse is more reliable while circuit breaker is more convenient and easier to use; therefore, I recommend you to use a bit higher rated fuse along with a circuit breaker to have a perfect pair. This will give you all the benefits of circuit breakers along with the reliability of fuses.
In case you are using fuse and circuit breaker together, you should make sure that your fuse has higher amp rating than your circuit breaker. But it should not exceed your wiring’s maximum amp rating. Calculation of Ampere Rating for your Circuit Breaker: In order to take full benefit of a circuit breaker, you will need to calculate its ampere rating using the following guide lines.
- Make a list of all your electric appliances.
- Check all the appliances for their amps and write them in the list in front of their names.
- In case you can only find Watt or VA of the appliance then you can calculate Amp by dividing the Watt or VA by your mains volt.
Ampere = Watt (W) / Volts (V)
For example, if you see 12W written on an LED bulb and your main supply is 240V then the amps of that bulb will be 12/240=0.05A
- Calculate the total Amps and add a 25% margin for your power sockets and startup loads if possible. For example, if your total load is 20A then you should install a 25A (20 x 1.25=25A) circuit breaker if your wiring can hold it.
- Remember your wiring’s amp rating is the maximum allowed amp rating for everything.
. Similarly, a 1000W electric heater will take 4.17A. (1000/240=4.17A)
Remember! Never install an over rated fuse in your fuse box. It is your last line of defense against electric short circuits.
Posted or Updated On:Jun 10, 2019